MINUTES
MEMBERSHIP DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL MEETINGS
AMERICAN SOCIETY OF AGRICULTURAL ENGINEERS
July 1999
Sheraton Centre, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
MEMBERSHIP DEVELOPMENT
COUNCIL Sunday, July 18, 1999 1:30 - 3:30 pm Windsor E Room
Stanley A. Weeks, presiding
1. CALL TO ORDER AND OPENING
REMARKS
Council Chair Stanley Weeks
called the meeting of the Membership Development Council to order at 1:30 pm on
Sunday, July 18, 1999, in the Windsor East Room of the Sheraton Centre,
Toronto, Ontario Canada. Those present included S. A. Weeks (Council Chair), R.
M. Peart (District 2 Rep.), R. N. Clark (Awards Chair), J. E. Dixon
(International Committee Rep.), D. D. Fangmeier (Section Committee Rep.), J. F.
Reid (District 3 Rep.), D. L. Larson (District 4 Rep.-elect), R. A. Persyn
(Student Rep.), J. L. Wille (Past Chair), D. B. Beasley (District 2
Rep.-elect), J. S. Cundiff (FPEI Rep.), G. A. Giacomelli (District 1 Rep.) , D.
L. Wambeke (District 5 Rep.), R. E. Yoder (P-414 Chair), C. L. Weller (P-414
Vice Chair), R. B. Dodd (NCEES Rep. To Participating Organizations Liaison
Committee), R. E. Graves (PEI Rep.), J. L. Steele (Vice Chair), J. S. Cundiff
(FPEI Rep.), M. D. Zielke (Comptroller), D. J. Thar (Administrative Assistant),
and M. M. Moore (Executive Vice President). A. L. Kenimer (Education Dept.
Rep), J. B. Solie (Research Committee Rep.), and C. E. Brown (District 4 Rep.)
were absent.
Mr. Weeks indicated that Ann
Kenimer advised that the Education Steering Committee (P-202) is in the process
of being disbanded.
He distributed copies of
Membership Development Council reports that were given to the Board of Trustees
on December 10, 1998 and April 24, 1999 (Attachment A). Executive Vice
President Moore advised that Pam Manning will be returning from pregnancy leave
January 1, 2000, and Tina Schultz will be returning September 1, 1999.
2. REVIEW OF AGENDA
Additional items added to the
agenda under item #17:
17.1 Sam Houston State
University request to organize a Student Branch 17.2 Data Base Access of
Membership Information 17.3 Graduate Students 17.4 Section Termination 17.5
Student Member Qualifications 17.6 Member-Get-A-Member
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 18, 1999 Page 2
3. MINUTES OF THE JULY 12
& 16, 1998 MEETINGS
Mr. Russell Persyn advised
that he was present at the meetings in July 1998. An editorial change in
Attachment 5 was also corrected. It was MOVED AND VOTED to:
Approve the minutes of the
Membership Development Council of July 12 and 16, 1998 as corrected.
Mr. Del Fangmeier suggested
that future minutes reflect what business transpired on each of the two days.
Past Chair Jerry Wille asked that the minutes be sent out in a timely manner
(six weeks or sooner). 4. RESULTS OF EMAIL VOTING
Ms. Moore presented the email
votes for the period from July 16, 1998 through July 18, 1999 (Attachment B).
It was MOVED AND VOTED to:
Reaffirm the email votes for
Issue No. 98-6, Acceptance of the Florida A&M Application for a Student
Branch; Issue No. 98.7, North Atlantic Section/NABEC/Section Rebate Moneys; and
Issue No. 98.8 Connecticut Valley and East Lake Ontario Sections/NABEC Section
Rebate Moneys.
Awards Director R. Nolan Clark
discussed Issue No. 99.1, ASAE Foundation Scholarship Fund (Attachment C). He
indicated that the Student Engineer of the Year Scholarship (Yoerger) awards a
$1,000 scholarship and has a balance of $1,968. This scholarship has been in
existence for a number of years but has not been awarded every year because of
a lack of funds. A concern was expressed by P-207 as to the relevance of
creating another scholarship when there is an existing fund for the same
purpose.
Some Council members objected
to the restricted nature in which the proposal was written. Mr. Clark advised
that the scholarship awards are handled through P207. It was MOVED AND
SECONDED to affirm the vote on Issue 99-1 with the stipulation that details of
the requirements, solicitation, and selection be done by P-207. This motion was
ultimately withdrawn.
Past Chair Jerry Wille
expressed concern that the Foundation came directly to the Membership
Development Council before presenting their request to the Awards Committee.
This is totally inappropriate and is the major reason that the Council is
wrestling with making a decision.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 18, 1999 Page 3
Foundation President David
Palmer advised that Operations Committee chair Bill Splinters main thrust
is to get all of the awards endowed. He is optimistic that if Mr. Yoerger
decides not to endow the Student Engineering of the Year award in two years, an
appeal for a cause for giving to endow this award could be accomplished after
further discussion.
It was MOVED AND VOTED to:
Affirm Issue 99-1, Foundation
Scholarship Fund (a new Endowment-in-Process fund).
5. BUDGET
Jerry Wille, past chair of the
Membership Development Council, explained the budget process. He advised that
the Membership Development Council has oversight for $1.2M in expenses and
$850,000 in income. The income comes from dues (including the portion
attributed to Resource magazine), $8,000 from the Foundation and $2,300 in
royalties from the MBNA credit cards. The Council should determine, at one
point, if it should continue the MBNA program. During budget consideration, the
Council must also consider the needs of the committees within its purview.
5.1 PE Exam Preparation
Engineering Registration
Committee (P-414) Chair, Ron Yoder, discussed the budget needs of P-414. P-414
has two budget requests for consideration by the Council:
1) A budget increase of $5,000
(from $3,000 to $8,000) to cover increased costs of developing the exam; and 2)
$20,000 to complete a Task Analysis required by NCEES.
Mr. Yoder discussed the
requests and offered an overview of NCEES and the requirements P-414 must meet
to provide the exam each year. This is included in Attachment D. The request
for a budget increase was deferred until Thursday. Further discussion focused
on the Task Analysis request.
The Task Analysis is required
by NCEES. It is a survey of most of the professional working engineers within a
discipline and done to ensure that the exam reflects what work is actually
performed by people within the discipline. P-414 will form a committee of 7-10
members to develop the survey and headquarters assistance will be needed on
mailing and receipt of the surveys. NCEES will perform the analysis of the
survey. The Analysis will take about 14 months to complete. The $20,000 request
includes $16,000 to convene the committee (7-10 people) twice and $4,000 to
NCEES (or its subcontractor) to cover the preparation and printing of the
computer analyzed survey forms.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 18, 1999 Page 4
Mr. Yoder noted that the new
task analysis would introduce more of a biological component to the exam. This
is of great interest to some. However, it will never be a biological exam. If
the Task Analysis indicates that the practicing agricultural engineers are
involved in biological applications, the exam will have more of a biological
emphasis in some of the questions.
In summary comments, Mr. Dodd,
ASAE representative to the NCEES Participating Organizations Liaison Committee,
pointed out that the original agreement between NCEES and ASAE was to provide a
camera-ready exam to NCEES. Over the years ASAE has used NCEES' facility and
staff to help prepare the exam - even to the point of having an NCEES staff
person attend a workshop at an ASAE annual meeting to help prepare the exam.
NCEES has been very gracious and willing to help in the past years. He also
noted that two or three years ago some members of the P-414 committee were not
inclined to change the structure to a no-choice exam. However, they were
pressed hard by NCEES to make the change and have concluded that they could
write an exam that would essentially test the same knowledge and pass the same
people with a no-choice exam as with the previous exam format. They simply have
to be more careful in writing the questions so they reflect basic engineering
principles. It was MOVED AND SECONDED to: Budget $20,000 to fund the task
analysis every 10 years.
Mr. Weeks indicated that this
is a good example for use of the Initiative Fund since it is a one time thing
that initiates something and gets it in motion. He suggested developing a
strong Initiative Fund proposal for funds available next year. This would be a
solid way to approach this without increasing the budget. Mr. Wille agreed on
pursuing the Initiative Fund. If that is not approved then pursue the ASAE
Foundation. It was MOVED AND SECONDED to table the motion until Thursday.
MOTION FAILED.
It was MOVED AND VOTED to:
Amend the motion to delete
"budget" from the motion.
It was MOVED AND VOTED that:
The Membership Development
Council endorse moving forward on funding $20,000 for the task analysis.
The Task Force to develop an
Initiative Fund proposal will consist of Chair Jerry Wille, David Beasley, and
Ron Yoder.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 18, 1999 Page 5
6. REPORTS
6.1 Headquarters
No further report, see opening
remarks.
6.2 Awards
Awards Director Nolan Clark
advised that five awards are not being presented this year. There has been some
criticism, but there were insufficient nominees for these five awards. It is
the discretion of the Selection Committee not to choose one of the nominees if
they so desire in order to maintain the quality and excellence of the ASAE
awards program. This year the Awards presentation will be a banquet rather than
a lunch and a dessert reception will follow to give members an opportunity to
congratulate the award winners.
He advised that the new Award
for the Advancement of Surface Irrigation will be announced during the Business
Meeting. This award will be presented beginning in 2000. 6.3 Report of District
1
District 1 Representative Gene
Giacomelli presented a report on District 1 (Attachment E).
6.4 Report of District 2
District 2 Representative Robert Peart reported that all the Sections in
District 2 are doing well. He introduced incoming District 2 Representative,
David Beasley.
6.5 Report of District 3
District 3 Representative John
Reid will report on Thursday.
6.6 Report of District 4 In
the absence of District 4 Representative Claude Brown, Del Fangmeier reported
that the New Mexico Section is inactive but there is a candidate who will work
to revive it; Arizona and Colorado are fairly static; California-Nevada Section
is doing well, and Hawaii is inactive.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 18, 1999 Page 6
6.7 Report of District 5
District 5 Representative Dan
Wambeke reported that the Pacific Northwest Section includes Alberta, Alaska,
British Columbia, Idaho, Montana, Oregon, Utah, and Washington. The four
northwest states are having an annual meeting in Logan, Utah. Several states do
not have agricultural and biological engineering programs. The Pacific
Northwest Section has an annual meeting and attracts about 100 participants. In
the Midwest the prairie provinces have three sections, South Dakota which is
inactive, Red River Valley which has three meetings a year, and the Man-Sask
Section (Manitoba, Saskatchewan). These Sections have a North Central meeting
which is held in March/April. The Sections go relatively inactive for two
years. Every three years they become active to put on the North Central
meeting.
6.8 Report of Education
No report.
6.9 Report of the
International Commission
International Commission chair
John Dixon commented that there needs to be a policy on the use of the term
"agricultural engineering." If ASAE continues to use American Society of
Agricultural Engineers on all publications, this will solve the problem from
the international point of view. The official wording also needs to be included
on ASAEs stationery. Executive Vice President Moore advised that the
letterhead for ASAE is being redesigned and American Society of Agricultural
Engineers will be spelled out somewhere on the letterhead.
6.10 Research
No report.
6.11 Professional Development
No report.
6.12 Section Steering
Section Steering Committee
chair Del Fangmeier discussed Section Awards. Last January Joe Schulz provided
a list of statistics pertaining to membership, particularly changes during the
period 1996-1998. Later he sent a suggestion for certificates to be sent out to
recognize those sections where membership increased for their efforts. There
were two categories:
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 18, 1999 Page 7
First based on the percentage
increase in membership from 1996 to 1998: Georgia Section highest percentage
increase in Regular members; Oklahoma Section highest percentage increase in
Student members; Oklahoma Section highest percentage increase in total
membership.
Second based on the numerical
increase in membership from 1996 to 1998: Quad Cities Section highest numerical
increase in regular members; Kansas Section highest numerical increase in
Student members; Georgia Section highest numerical increase in total
membership.
Mr. Fangmeier read a sample
certificate "The Membership Development Council of the American Society of
Agricultural Engineers hereby honors the officers and members of the Georgia
Section for outstanding regular membership growth of the section during the
period 1996-1998."
It was MOVED AND VOTED to:
Recognize the Georgia and
Oklahoma Sections on the basis of increases in total members An additional
award was given to James W. "Bill" Thomas in recognition for his efforts in the
development of new Student Branches in the Texas Section.
It was suggested giving a
certificate to any Section that increases their membership most in each
category. The important thing is that people are recognized and the data are
distributed so people understand what is happening in various sections.
6.13 Preprofessionals
Mr. Russell Persyn reported
that the Foundation endowed the Preprofessional Fund last year. The committee,
consisting of Mr. Persyn, Carly Washmon, Bob Fridley, and Barrie Smith proposed
to distribute $1,000 from the fund in the following manner:
$250 1st Place 1/4 Scale Team
$200 2nd Place 1/4 Scale Team
$250 1st Place Poster
Competition $150 2nd Place Poster Competition $100 3rd Place Poster Competition
$50 Trophy for Micro Mini
Tractor Pull Competition
These distributions are to be
used to assist in travel to the Annual Meeting.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 18, 1999 Page 8 This proposal was approved by the
Preprofessionals at their Business Meeting.
Mr. Persyn advised that the
issue of the cost of the annual meeting, hotel accommodations, etc. were
discussed at the Preprofessional Business meeting. A suggestion of a check-off
program to members be made to offset cost (on a voluntary basis) for student
members attending the meeting. He was encouraged to visit with the Meetings
Council.
7. OTHER BUSINESS
7.1 Mr. Weeks presented a
Leadership Citation to Del Fangmeier "For his distinguished leadership in
organizing and serving as chair of the newly formed Section Steering Committee,
the first meeting of this committee, at the 1998 Annual Meeting, was very
successful and this group will be vital in assisting sections activities."
7.2 Treasurer Roger Rohrbach
distributed a copy of and addressed the Electronic Publishing Initiative
Potential Impact on Other Business Units and Overall Society Finances
(Attachment F).
The meeting recessed at 3:35
pm until Thursday at 7 am.
MEMBERSHIP DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL
Thursday, July 22, 1999 7:00-10:00 am Civic North Ballroom
Stanley A. Weeks, presiding
1. CALL TO ORDER AND OPENING
REMARKS
The Membership Development
Council meeting reconvened at 7:00 am Thursday, July 22, 1999. Those present
included S. A. Weeks (Chair), R. M. Peart (District 2), R. N. Clark (Awards
Chair), J. E. Dixon (International Committee Rep.), D. D. Fangmeier (Section
Committee Rep.), J. F. Reid (District 3 Rep.), D. L. Larson (District 4
Rep.-elect), R. A. Persyn (Student Rep.), J. L. Wille (Past Chair), D. B.
Beasley (District 2 Rep.-elect), C. E. Brown (District 4 Rep.), R. E. Yoder
(P-414 Chair), J. L. Steele (Vice Chair), S. G. Capps (Society Trustee), G.
Singh (Trustee), M. D. Zielke (Comptroller), D. J. Thar (Administrative
Assistant), and M. M. Moore (Executive Vice President). Section Steering
committee incoming chair Ted Tyson and incoming Preprofessional representative
Carly Washmon were also present. A. L. Kenimer (Education Dept. Rep.) and J. B.
Solie (Research Committee Rep.) were absent. Malcolm Wright represented Robert
Graves (PEI Rep.). Douglas Small representing Jan Jofriet for CSAE and Saied
Mostaghimi representing the Soil & Water Division were also present.
OLD BUSINESS
2. AGENDA ITEMS DEFERRED FROM
SUNDAY, JULY 18 AGENDA
5.1 PE Exam Preparation
Mr. Jerry Wille discussed the
reimbursement of member travel for the PE exam preparation. It was MOVED AND
VOTED to:
Increase the budgeted travel
allowance from $3,000 to $8,000 for members traveling to NCEES to prepare the
PE exam.
5.2 Reimbursement of Member
Travel
Mr. Wille presented an
Initiative Fund Proposal for P-414: Engineering Licensure (Attachment G). The
request is in the amount of $18,640 to cover the cost of conducting a Task
Analysis for the agricultural engineering professional licensure examination.
(Ron Yoder discussed this need extensively under item #5.1 on Sunday).
It was MOVED AND VOTED to:
Support the Initiative Fund
Request proposal for funding the Task Analysis required by NCEES in the amount
of $18,640.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 22, 1999 Page 2
ASAE Society Trustee Brown
advised the Council that the Board of Trustees has been discussing
reimbursement of travel expense (Attachment H). He presented a proposal which
will be put before the Board of Trustees at its meeting. This needs to be
approved by the Board of Trustees.
After discussion of the
proposal, it was MOVED AND VOTED to
Amend the word "per diem" to
read "actual expenses."
6.2 Awards
Awards Coordinating Committee
(M-102) Chair Nolan Clark advised that nominations for awards to be presented
in 2000 are due October 31, 1999. An announcement will appear in the August or
September issue of Resource magazine. All award instructions are available on
the ASAE Home Page.
M-102 is working with
individual committees to present two new awards in 2000. Both of these were
discussed at the Societys Business Meeting on Tuesday.
M-102 received a verbal
request from the ¼ Scale Tractor contest committee to develop an umbrella
awards category for Student Design Competitions to include AGCO National
Student Design Competition, ¼ Scale Tractor Design Competition and an
Environmental Design Competition. No action was taken until a written request
is submitted.
Questions were raised about
the Student Contest committees - K. K. Barnes Student Paper (M-123), Student
Design Competition (M-124), and EMI Student Trophies (M-125). Mr. Clark advised
that these contests are in the awards area and that these competitions are not
in their proper organizational place. He requested that Council Chair Weeks
appoint a committee to address the issues of coordination of these student
activities with awards and student organizations. The committee consists of
Nolan Clark, Russell Persyn and Dennis Larson. John Cundiff was elected chair
of M-102 for 1999-2001.
6.5 Report of District 3
District 3 representative John
Reid advised that the Chicago Section and Central Illinois Section of ASAE are
in the process of being reactivated. He requested that disbandment be delayed
to allow these sections to become active. Officers need to be elected in order
to disburse funds currently available for each Section.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 22, 1999 Page 3
Mr. Fangmeier pointed out that
the Chicago Section has hosted the Winter Meeting for many years and perhaps
has accumulated a significant bank account. Mr. Reid will contact the former
treasurer. There was discussion regarding section bank accounts. Mr. Tyson
indicated that the issue is not a fund management problem but rather a problem
with active membership. Mr. Weeks suggested that the Section Guide be updated
by the Section Steering Committee to reflect the concerns discussed.
6.6 Report of District 4
District 4 representative
Claude Brown advised that Melissa Moore and John Miles have discussed creating
sub-sections within the areas of Section 4 in order to get activity back into
the organization. They will be following up on their discussions after the
Annual Meeting.
6.9 Report of International
Commission
International Commission Chair
John Dixon reported that the International Commission recommends that the ASAE
representative for CIGR report to ASAE through the International Activities
Committee (INTL 611).
It was MOVED AND VOTED that:
The ASAE representative for
CIGR report to ASAE through the International Activities Committee (INTL 611).
The International Commission
recommends that a partnering program of CIGR people and ASAE people be
established for matching people with similar technical interests as a part of
the forthcoming Joint Congress in 2002 (Attachment I).
It was MOVED AND VOTED that:
A partnering program of CIGR
and ASAE be established for matching people with similar technical interests as
a part of the forthcoming Joint Congress in 2002.
Mr. Dixon advised that the
International Commission appointed a working group to study appropriate data,
in concert with the headquarters staff, and to make recommendations concerning
the services and fees associated with the approved cooperative agreement
policy.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 22, 1999 Page 4
6.11 Report of Professional
Development
Mr. Malcolm Wright gave a
summary of activities for the Professional Engineering Institute (PEI)
(Attachment J). He advised that the PEI received a Presidential Citation for
their initiative and efforts in promoting the profession through the
publication "What a Consulting Agriculture Engineer Can Do For You" distributed
with the June 1999 issue of Resource magazine. Bill Koenig and Donna Hull were
recognized for their extraordinary efforts.
6.12 Report of Section
Steering Committee
Mr. Del Fangmeier reported on
the Section Steering Committee (Attachment K). He advised that the Minnesota
Section has a non-member treasurer. Ms. Moore indicated she would send a letter
to the president of the section explaining the situation and hopefully get him
to join ASAE.
Ted Tyson is the incoming
Section Steering Committee chair. 6.13 Report of Preprofessionals
Mr. Russell Persyn reported on
the activities of the Preprofessionals. The Quarter Scale Tractor competition
needs more visibility within ASAE. The Quarter Scale Tractor Competition
Committee (M-126) would like to have more banners and items to display at the
annual pull to show ASAE support and involvement with this design competition.
The Student Organization
Committee (P-207) suggested and passed a resolution to support a priority
listing from Preprofessionals to ASAE Headquarters. Furthermore, it was
suggested that the students subscribe each of their departmental student list
serves to the students@asae.org list serve to better serve and reach all
members and potential members of the Society with information.
At their meeting in Orlando,
the Membership Development Council discussed changing the membership form to
include the graduation date. He inquired to see the progress of this action and
reinforced follow up with students closer to their graduation date. Ms. Moore
advised that this is an initiative at headquarters.
Mr. Persyn expressed concern
that Resource magazine and other Society mailings that are sent in bulk to the
university may not be an effective means of reaching student members since some
universities are unable to have these distributed. Many students may not be in
the building of their department and do not come by to pick them up. They
encourage consideration be given to sending these directly to the student's
address. An electronic version of Resource and the ability to change address
information on the web, may alleviate some moving problems that students
frequently experience. Ms. Moore will work with Mr. Persyn to determine an
appropriate mailing system for the students.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 22, 1999 Page 5
Mr. Persyn advised that he and
Ms. Washmon met with the Meetings Council to resolve hotel accommodations for
the students. Carly Washmon is the incoming Preprofessional representative for
the Membership Development Council.
7. CHICAGO SECTION
See District 3 report (agenda
item 6.5)
8. PROFESSIONAL ETHICS
Mr. Weeks asked for volunteers
to communicate with Murray Madsen regarding the Code of Ethics for ASAE. A copy
of the email discussions appear as Attachment L. Malcolm Wright and Dennis
Larson volunteered.
9. MEMBERSHIP COMPOSITION
Mr. Steele advised that the
Membership Composition Committee has been inactive. He recommends that the
committee be retained and report back next year. It has not been determined who
will be members and their terms of office. Mr. Wille felt that the reason for
this committee is not to create a new Council, but rather review the bylaws and
determine how the Membership Development Council can function in the manner in
which it is constituted. This Council deals with an enormous amount of business
within the Society.
District 3 representative John
Reid asked for clarification of the process for replacing the district
representatives. Mr. Fangmeier advised that the Section Steering Committee
established that the Nominating Committee for the Districts will be the
district representative and section chairs from each of the sections within
that district. The election for District representatives will occur in the
spring of 2000.
John Dixon expressed a similar
concern about the International Commission representative in that there is no
procedure for selecting the Membership Development Council representative. The
Membership Development Council Bylaws state that the International Commission
Steering Committee will provide a member to the Council. (Article 2, Section B)
10. COOPERATIVE AGREEMENT
POLICY
Discussed under item 6.9,
Report of International Commission
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 22, 1999 Page 6
11. COUNCIL ORGANIZATION 11.1
Bylaws
See Attachment M.
11.2 Term of Office Mr. Weeks
suggested that the term of office for the Membership Development Council chair
be reconsidered, with the possibility of going to a two year term. With one
year terms, the chair-elect needs to be heavily involved in order to get up to
speed, and the past chair is head of the Budget Committee.
11.3 Nominating Committee Mr.
Steele reported that the Nominating Committee was appointed by Mr. Weeks. The
incoming vice chair, James Steele, was the chair of the Nominating Committee
which included Del Fangmeier and Robert Peart. An email message was sent to all
members of the Council requesting information for recommendations. The
committee met in Toronto prior to this Membership Development Council meeting
and selected a nominee from a group of three recommendations. Mr. R. Nolan
Clark was nominated for election as vice chair of the Membership Development
Council. It was MOVED AND VOTED to:
Accept the Nominating
Committee report.
It was MOVED AND VOTED to:
Cast an unanimous ballot for
R. Nolan Clark as incoming vice chair of the Membership Development Council.
12. GUIDELINES FOR COMMUNITY
DUES
Ms. Moore advised that the
Guidelines for Community Dues are being discussed by the Finance Committee and
the Board of Trustees. A task force is being established by the Board of
Trustees to look at all aspects of communities.
13. PRIORITY ISSUES RESPONSES
Mr. Weeks distributed a copy
of the "Big 5 Compilation" (Attachment N) and the Membership Development Plan
(Attachment O). The incoming chair will discuss these at future meetings.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 22, 1999 Page 7
14. ELECTRONIC PUBLISHING
Mr. Weeks indicated that the
electronic publishing is a positive effort for ASAE. A copy of the Electronic
Publishing Initiative appears as Attachment F. 15. OTHER ORGANIZATIONS
REPORTING
Ms. Moore discussed Other
Organization Reporting to ASAE. There are two groups that currently report to
the Board of Trustees Junior Engineering Technical Society (JETS) and
National Engineering Week (E-Week). The recommendation is that these two groups
report directly to the Membership Development Council. It was MOVED AND VOTED
to:
Accept the recommendation that
JETS and E-Week report directly to the Membership Development Council.
16.
REGIONS/SECTIONS/SUBSECTIONS
Ms. Moore advised that by
eliminating regions, the sections became very large. Discussions with NABEC
indicated they would go back to a region. There is a bylaw change that would be
required if regions were reinstated. Mr. Fangmeier indicated that the Section
Steering Committee discussed the issue of establishing regions. The general
reaction was to stay with the current set-up for the present time. The Section
Steering Committee bylaws include district reps, section reps and reps from
other geographic units.
17. ITEMS INTRODUCED AFTER THE
PUBLICATION OF AGENDA 17.1 Sam Houston State University Request to Organize a
Student Branch
Ms. Moore presented a petition
from Professor Billy Harrell, Department of Agricultural Sciences, Sam Houston
State University, Huntsville, Texas, to form the SHSU Agricultural
Mechanization Club (SHSU Ag Mech Club) (Attachment P). Since the students had
left campus before signing the petition, Professor Harrell will obtain all
signatures upon their return. It was MOVED AND VOTED to:
Approve the establishment of
the SHSU Agricultural Mechanization Club with the recognition that the
signatures will be obtained.
17.2 Data Base Access of
Member Information
Ms. Moore asked the Membership
Development Council to establish a committee to review the issue of member
access and member privacy. The committee consists of: Del Fangmeier, Carly
Washmon, John Dixon, and Dennis Larson, chair.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 22, 1999 Page 8
17.3 Graduate Students
Ms. Moore advised of a request
to establish a committee or group for graduate students since there is no
current networking group for grad students. Mr. Persyn indicated that one of
the reasons the name of the student group was changed to Preprofessionals was
to accommodate all students not just undergraduate. Ms. Washmon advised that
the Preprofessional officers will be working with the graduate students and ag
mechs to be more inclusive at the national level. Also, the reorganization of
the Student Manual on the web site will make it very clear that
Preprofessionals includes all students ag systems, engineering and
graduate students.
17.4 Section Termination
No report.
17.5 Member-Get-A-Member
Ms. Moore advised that the
current Member-Get-A-Member program awards a $20 gift certificate to members
who recruit a new member. She asked for the Councils advice on using the
certificate to pay the members own dues. From a philosophical nature, it
is sending the wrong message of getting a new member and then paying dues with
the award. Mr. Tyson advised not pursuing the issue since such a small
percentage of members use it to offset their dues. The Council concurred with
leaving the program as is.
NEW BUSINESS
3. ITEMS INTRODUCED AFTER THE
PUBLICATION OF AGENDA
3.1 Report on Biological
Engineering (BE) Division
ASAE Society Trustee Susan
Capps reported on the proposed Biological Engineering Division. She advised
that 81 members endorsed the proposal and 7 others were interested. A copy of
those names and notes on the Rap Session appear as Attachment R. The mission
and goals of the BE Division appear as Attachment S. Pending appointment by the
president, the proposed officers for the BE Division are: Chair Mark
Riley; Vice Chair Scott Osborn; Secretary Susan Capps; and Past
Chair Joel Cuello. Ms. Capps asked that a list serve be developed for
the BE division of everyone who has indicated biological engineering as their
primary or secondary career interest.
It was MOVED AND VOTED that:
The Membership Development
Council enthusiastically supports the concept of a Biological Engineering (BE)
Division within ASAE.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 22, 1999 Page 9
3.2 Proposal Concerning
Resource Magazine
David Beasley advised that the
Membership Publications Editorial Board (P-513) has been discussing how to
improve the usability, distribution, potential for advertising, and other
issues related to Resource magazine. One of the concerns is that the articles
are not first-run, that they are being taken from other publications. The
magazine needs to represent ASAE in total to retain and inform members. It also
should be a very strong item for promoting what ASAE is and what ASAE does, as
well as communicating with the general public. P-513 has embarked upon the
process of a membership survey which may be included in Resource magazine. The
possible survey questions include: how to improve; favorite parts of magazine;
what would you like to see. He advised that Jimmy Butt initiated the
discussion. A proposal concerning Resource Magazine appears as Attachment T.
It was MOVED AND VOTED that:
The Membership Development
Council supports improvements to Resource magazine.
4. ORGANIZATION OF THE COUNCIL
FOR 1999-2000 Mr. Steele advised that there are three Standing Committees:
Budget Committee; Nominating Committee; and Bylaws Committee. The chair of the
Budget Committee is the past chair of the Membership Development Council, Stan
Weeks. Members include MDC Vice chair Nolan Clark and the Awards chair John
Cundiff. The Bylaws Committee consists of Nolan Clark, chair, Ted Tyson, and
David Beasley. Ted Tyson will be the Section Committee Rep.
5. SCHEDULE FOR MEMBERSHIP
DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL MEETINGS
Mr. Steele indicated that the
Membership Development Council will not meet until the next Annual
International meeting in Milwaukee, but will be communicating via email. It was
MOVED AND VOTED to:
Continue to use email
balloting.
6. RECOGNITION OF RETIRING
COUNCIL MEMBERS
Mr. Weeks recognized retiring
Membership Development Council members. He commended past chair Jerry Wille for
three years of struggle with the reorganization and leadership of the Council
through the new budget process and Initiative Fund development.
Minutes of the Membership
Development Council, July 22, 1999 Page 10
7. PASSING OF GAVEL TO
1999/2000 CHAIR
Mr. Weeks passed the gavel to
1999/2000 chair James L. Steele.
8. CLOSING REMARKS
Mr. Steele shared his thoughts
for the coming year. The focus for the next year will likely be in streamlining
the operations of the Membership Development Council, with some clarification
in scheduling of Membership Development Council actions, some type of regular
Membership Development Council communication updates, development of email
ballot questions, Membership Development Council input on "member connectivity"
and coordination of some efforts to revitalize a number of inactive Sections.
9. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting was adjourned at
10 am.
Respectfully submitted,
M. Melissa Moore, Executive
Vice President
Dorothy J. Thar,
Secretary/Recorder
Electronic
copy from Mark Crossley, June 15, 2000. jlsteele
Will look into
adding attachments next week. jlsteele
Last update:
June 16, 2000 jlsteele
|